The same jacket in another hide is another jacket: the weight, the softness, the way it shines, how it takes rain. Here are the five we use, compared from the wearer's side.
Horsehide - heavy, and the one that ages best
Thick and dense. The pores are open, so it takes up water and oil and changes with the person wearing it. It is hard-wearing, holds its colour, and builds shine and depth the more you wear it. Nearly all tea-core leather is horsehide.
It is heavy. This is the hide you choose when you intend to wear a jacket in.
Goatskin - light, and comfortable from day one
Light and supple, easy on the shoulders over a long day, with a fine grain and more strength than it looks. It will not develop the heft of horsehide, but it is wearable the day you buy it.
- Cafe Racer J-100, Goatskin (three colours)
- Short A-2, Tea-Core Goatskin
Cowhide and calf - tight-grained, and it holds its shape
Cowhide is thick with an even surface; finished in oil wax it takes a deep shine and develops grain. Calf is finer again and keeps a crisp silhouette. Both take a vintage finish well, with mottling and shadow.
Sheepskin - the softest of them
Soft, and it follows the body from the moment you put it on. It is also the hide used when the fleece is left on for a mouton collar, and for cold-weather pieces. Not the hide you pick for toughness - but nothing beats it for comfort.
Deerskin - dense, quiet, unusual
Usually water-dyed and left uncoated, which gives it a soft, clinging hand you do not get elsewhere. There is not much of it about, and it asks for care.
- Leather Tailored Jacket, Natural Black 1920s Deerskin
- Jerkin Vest, Water-Dyed WWI Deerskin (made to order)
If you are undecided
- To wear in over ten years - horsehide
- To wear every day, lightness first - goatskin
- To keep a clean silhouette - cowhide or calf
- For softness above all - sheepskin
- For a soft, clinging hand, and something less common - deerskin
The closer a hide is to uncoated, the less it likes rain. Wipe it dry, let it air in the shade, and add oil only once it starts to feel dry.